arizona audit updates

Nearly six months after President Joe Biden won Arizona by nearly 10,500 votes and Maricopa County by over 45,100 votes, auditors are set to hand count 2.1 million ballots in the county. But Bennett said that, in some ways, thats no surprise. Those who cast ballots but now live in different areas may have moved since the election, or moved out of a parents house around Election Day. An audit of 2020 U.S. presidential election results in Maricopa County, Arizona, has not shown that former U.S. President Donald Trump won over 700,000 more votes than previously thought. He also cast doubt on any analysis done by the Senates "signature expert," Shiva Ayyadurai, and said Sen. Kelly Townsend was "using the discredited work of Ayyadurai as a basis for this new subpoena.". [1/6]People gather outside Arizona Government building ahead of the announcement of interim findings from a widely criticized audit of the 2020 election in Phoenix, Arizona, September 24, 2021. The Cyber Ninjas are raising that money from anonymous third parties . Republican former U.S. Rep. John Shadegg was hired to oversee the review of computer routers and logs that the board said contained information from across the county. At the time Bennett questioned the transparency of cyber-ninjas, the group in charge of the operation. The count raises more questions about Cyber Ninjas than Maricopa. Hear from both sides of the aisle - CBS 13's Cody Lee reports. . The audit is being funded through partisan sponsors including MyPillow CEO Mike Lindell and a nonprofit set up by a reporter for One America News Network, which has been given exclusive access to livestream from the audit site. A subscription helps you access more of the local stories that keep you connected to the community. The mechanics of the Maricopa County assessment have little in common with traditional attempts to ensure the accuracy of a vote. Whats happening in Arizona is also a kind of recount, but it doesnt reflect a traditional one of those either. The report was the latest to find no evidence of any major problems with the election in Maricopa County. Sorry, you need to enable JavaScript to visit this website. Fann said she had passed along the review's findings to Arizona Attorney General Mark Brnovich, who said his election integrity unit would look at the evidence. It came down to: People split their ticket, he told Fox Business Neil Cavuto. - We The People News Monday, January 16, 2023 21:10 Video SITUATION UPDATE 1/16/23 (rumble.com) Share. In additionSee this and similar jobs on LinkedIn. Here are the 10 states with the least healthy populations. Cyber Ninjas matched voters with commercial data, rather than official data maintained by county elections office. And Logan has made no claims like that since. Tempe, Gilbert, Glendale, Flagstaff, and Chandler, BeachFleischman provides accounting, audit, consulting, and tax services to businesses, organizations, and individuals (U.S. and foreign-based), doing business domestically and internationally. The Cyber Ninjas report includes several recommended areas that the firm suggests warrant further scrutiny, broken down by level of severity critical, high, medium, low and unknown (or, inits term, informational). The Arizona Senate on Friday heard testimony from the firm it hired to conduct a so-called audit of more than2 million votes cast in Maricopa County during the 2020 elections, the latest in a cavalcade of election disinformation spread at the behest of former President Trump. The judge found Cyber Ninjas in contempt for its failure to turn over documents, which two Maricopa County judges and the state Court of Appeals have ruled are subject to the public records law. Democratic Secretary of State Katie Hobbs said the audit was filled with security lapses, delays, disorganization and a lack of transparency. She said the review failed to meet industry standards for an audit, much less an election audit., And the Arizona Democratic Party already has scheduled a press conference to occur four hours before the report is released, calling it a farcical, conspiracy-driven audit that is a disgrace to our democratic processes., It isnt only Democrats, however, who have raised questions. The Senate established its authority to demand voting records from Maricopa County, or any other jurisdiction in Arizona responsible for running elections. The ballots from Maricopa County, Arizona have already been audited four times since. Findings from the Arizona audit released in September confirmed Biden beat Trump in the state. And its being performed months after the election, after votes have been certified, after the winners of said election have been sworn into office. "We spent four hours on Zoom today,'' she said late Thursday, saying the team is "still working on the final report.''. At the same time, some conspiracy theorists suggested that ballots had been imported from overseas. Click here to subscribe to any of our publications. Al Frankens U.S. Senate seat win in 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory in 2004, and a 2006 auditor race in Vermont. After more than five months and around $6 million (most of it privately raised among Trump supporters), the legendarily ludicrous Arizona audit of the 2020 election results from Maricopa County. No word on Steve's ability to read a footnote. He won the state by more than 10,000 votes, or 0.31 percent. In Arizona, for an election in which more than 25,000 ballots are cast, such as the presidential election, the margin of victory must be 200 or fewer votes. Circuit Court of Appeals to revive their lawsuit. The review and others like it may instead further erode trust in our elections. Here's what's been found in a race decided by 10,457 votes: 3,981 voted despite registered AFTER Oct 15 deadline. Tool can help customers get canceled flight refunds. But election analysts and experts said that figure is meaningless without more context. Senate President Karen Fann tells Arizona Supreme Court that judges can't force her to give up the documents now held by Cyber Ninjas. In many instances, the county said the audit team made glaring mistakes because it didn't understand election policies and procedures. Reporting by David Schwartz in Phoenix and Nathan Layne in Wilton, Connecticut; Additional reporting by Joseph Ax; Editing by Soyoung Kim, Howard Goller and Daniel Wallis, U.S. to announce international cryptocurrency action -statement, Exclusive: U.S. energy chief warns Republicans that oil bill would raise pump prices, Turkey's foreign minister to discuss F-16s and NATO during U.S. visit, Massachusetts man charged with wife's murder searched how to dispose of body - prosecutor, Blinken says he had no knowledge of documents taken to Penn Biden Center, Trump to make first 2024 campaign appearance in South Carolina, Texas electrical grid still at risk in extreme weather -Dallas Fed, U.S. Justice Department rolls out policy to coax companies to report wrongdoing, U.S. airlines do not see speedy return of China, Japan travel demand, See here for a complete list of exchanges and delays. I understand why people are frustrated.. In addition, there was no sign that any of the computer equipment in the countys Office of Enterprise Technology, which provides computer support for all the huge county departments, was compromised. Of those 31 recounts, just three reversed the outcome.2 In each of those races, the margin of victory before the recount was fewer than 300 votes and less than 0.06 percent of the votes cast. MARICOPA COUNTY, Ariz. (KYMA, KECY) - Per CNN, the first semi truck full of 2020 election ballots rolled slowly through the Arizona State Fairgrounds on Friday, past the "Crazy Times Carnival". BREAKING UPDATE: Arizona Court Of Appeals Schedules Conference In Kari Lake's Election Lawsuit, Agrees Case Should Be Expedited! A nationwide push by Democrats and journalists to find out more information about the controversial Arizona election audit being conducted by a little-known private company scored a small. Pac-12 Hotline mailbag: Who has the toughest football schedule next season? 9 Arizonas loss to Oregon in Eugene, Hobbs' budget includes child tax credit, K-12 boost, housing funds, Dr. Roach: High doses of vitamins lead to vitamin D toxicity, Watch now: Arizona Senate presents 2020 election recount results, Cyber Ninjas can be sued under Arizona's public records law, judge rules, Maricopa County deal ends Arizona Senate subpoena fight, Arizonans will finally get to see what 2020 election audit concluded, Arizona Supreme Court allows release of election audit records, Threatening email sent to Arizona GOP senator who withdrew support for election audit, Cyber Ninjas' audit documents to remain secret for at least 3 more weeks, Arizona Senate makes last-ditch effort to keep records of audit company secret, Maricopa County, Dominion Voting Systems defy new Arizona Senate subpoenas, Trump backers raise $5.6M for Arizona election audit, Arizona audit confirms Trump lost, finds no fraud, Trump supporters pepper Arizona's governor with demands he decertify election, Judge declines to cite Arizona Senate president with contempt over records delay, Judge rejects Arizona Senate's claim some election audit records are private, Another judge chides Arizona Senate for withholding public records on election audit, Arizona Senate to judge: Don't force us to immediately release audit records to public, New Arizona election report finds no county data issues, Brazil charges 39 people over pro-Bolsonaro riots, Vehicles struggle to navigate Denver roads during winter storm. Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Phoenix. That edge was enough to overcome Trump support in rural counties, giving Biden a final victory margin of 10,457 votes and the state's 11 electoral votes. Cyber Ninjas CEO Doug Logan, hired by Arizona's Senate Republican leaders to conduct an "audit" of the 2020 election in Maricopa County, was featured on a Thursday prayer call hosted by Intercessors for America, a network of "prayer warriors" that strongly backed former President Donald Trump. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Its not a poke in the eye thing. Download forApple iOSorAndroid. Bennett is reserving comment on whether any of those shortcomings were intentional, however. Anyone who spent time on the University of Arizona campus from 1968 to 1987 might recognize David C. Wright. Trump, who had predicted the Arizona inquiry would substantiate his claims, issued a statement that appeared at odds with the review's findings, calling it "a big win for democracy and a big win for us.". The Arizona Supreme Court said it will not decide the issue of whether those records are subject to public disclosure until at least Sept. 14. The Cyber Ninjas will soon present its findings publicly on Arizona's Senate floor regarding the conduct of the 2020 election. The audit was marked by practices that critics described as ranging from inappropriate to bizarre, including counters marking ballots with blue ink, which can alter how they are read by machines, and workers checking for traces of bamboo fibers based on a conspiracy theory that forged ballots may have been shipped in from Asia. Talk of similar exercises is being discussed in Michigan and New Hampshire, too. She produced a report claiming that, based on a sample of homes checked, there were more than 173,000 ballots that were lost and more than 96,000 ghost voters, ballots that were cast by people who did not exist. . Even after the majority-Republican Maricopa County Board of Supervisors hired two separate, independent firms to perform a forensic audit of the voting equipment used an audit which found no irregularities the state Senate was unsatisfied. 2023 www.azcentral.com. A full hand-count of ballots and review of election equipment done by contractors hired by the Senate and released in September found no major problems. Arizona's top elected official Katie Hobbs, a Democrat, in a statement denounced the review as "a political stunt that created massive security risks, cost millions of dollars, and has shaken faith in free and fair elections.". The states highest court said it will consider whether the Arizona Court of Appeals and a trial court properly rejected the Senates claim that the records were protected under legislative privilege. The. Continuing coverage: Arizona Election Audit. The report compiled by an outside special master and released by the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors on March 23 "should be a final stake in the heart of the Senate's so-called 'audit,'". Use the Audit Trail Bot to automate document workflows and Update Request for Information - Mechanic Liens - Corporation or LLC - Arizona in clicks. Here's what comes next in the partisan audit. It seems to be prompted by political motivations because the earlier counts and checks didnt produce the outcome that the legislators wanted.. Since then, it has . Ward even made a video about it (with a fundraising plea, no doubt, still to come). PHOENIX, Sept 24 (Reuters) - Donald Trump lost the 2020 presidential election to Joe Biden in Arizona's most populous county, a review of results by his allies in the Republican Party has reaffirmed, capping a widely panned effort spurred by Trump's false claims of voter fraud. FiveThirtyEight reached out to a spokesperson for Cyber Ninjas, but he did not respond to our questions. Arizona Supreme Court makes ruling on Maricopa County 2020 election audit lawsuit American Oversight filed the lawsuit last year to get access to about 1,000 records sent between Republican. For the past five weeks, workers from Cyber Ninjas, a small private cybersecurity company based in Sarasota, Florida, have gathered in an arena to re-recount all the ballots nearly 2.1 million at the behest of the states Republican senators. Brnovich, pointedly, did not cite any evidence offered by Cyber Ninjas. Byrne Hobart writes at thediff.co, analyzing inflections in finance and tech. . And there are three women who returned their recently deceased mothers early ballots. The only trulyserious vulnerability here is Brnovichs Senate campaign prospects, which is why I suspect that the attorney general who in 2020 had no problemwithArizonas election nowsuddenly does. The report, by a Republican ex-congressman, further undermines claims by some Trump supporters that Maricopa County machines were somehow hacked. 15 Jan 2023 07:03:11 . Because the normal requirements of an audit or a recount arent being followed, the results cant be trusted. More frustrating stillis what is happening in 2022. It is FREE! The most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs. We did identify a few where they fell short, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday. A judge on Tuesday rejected a state Senate claim that some of its records about the 2020 election audit are not subject to public disclosure. Using This Site. If everything went according to plan, the same number of ballots should have been counted in both elections ballots cast for the Democratic candidate, ballots cast for the Republican candidate, ballots cast for any third-party candidates and ballots that either did not record a vote, recorded too many votes or recorded a write-in vote. The Republican-led Arizona audit being conducted by the Florida-based tech company Cyber Ninjas took an unexpected turn after voter data was transported to a mystery "lab" in Montana to be. The full-hand recount of roughly 2.1 million certified ballots cast. I call on Arizona to decertify the election of 2020 and recall the electors, he said, though there appears to be no legal precedent for that. Despite the Arizona Democratic Party urging members not to participate in state Senate Republicans' audit of the 2020 presidential vote, Shacket went ahead and volunteered to find out what. District lacked internal controls and did not comply with requirements in multiple areas, putting public monies, sensitive computerized data, and student safety at risk. He claimed there are serious vulnerabilities in Arizonas electoralsystem, but he couldnt point to a single instance of a phony vote as a result. This special COVID-19 funding report presents information on the amounts, intended purposes, Department helps coordinate emergency management efforts throughout the State, but did not consistently develop and track corrective actions to address some emergency response deficiencies, impacting its ability toaddress these deficiencies during real-world emergency responses, and did not comply with Office provides economic, demographic, and tax research and analysis for the State but lacked documentation of benefits received for payments made to Commerce Authority, and Arizona Finance Authority, a related entity, lacked oversight controls for some key activities increasing risk for errors and fraud. Garrett Archer, a former top aide in the Arizona secretary of states office who now reports for Phoenixs ABC affiliate, told The Hill that the official data maintained by the county would have answered questions raised by the commercial data but that Cyber Ninjas did not take that step. This person will be recognized as the expert in systems administration who provides guidance and internal consulting expertise toward . Newly obtained documents from Arizona state lawmakers and leaders of the phony audit show that top Republican officials, Trump advisers, and other senior party figures were pushing for the. Subscribe to stay connected to Tucson. Doug Ducey. Likewise, recounts can ferret out inaccuracies. Not a word about bamboo. Im not going to say in a verbal interview what Im going to be putting in writing for the report, Bennett said. Democrats say such laws are aimed at gaming the system since Republicans tend to do better in low-turnout elections. Two of them live in Maricopa County, one in Cochise County. They wasted nearly $6 million to tell us what we already knew, meanwhile exacerbating an already unhealthy political environment, state Sen. Paul Boyer (R), an audit opponent, told The Hill in a text message. Must have - FDA QA experience to include having successfully completed an FDA audit. Standardization on these details would more greatly facilitate future audits, the report says. Review reports of audit work performed by the Internal Audit department over the 3 most recent fiscal years. Within hours of Brnovich's report, Republican legislative hopeful Steve Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising plea. In the words of the auditors themselves: [T]here were no substantial differences between the hand count of the ballots provided and the official canvass results for the County. Bobb aided Arizona Senate Republicans with the effort as early as December, new documents. But he did give the option of letting him see the records first and then deciding. Arizona election audit confirms Biden's win in Maricopa County, but also casts doubts By Ben Giles Published: Thursday, September 23, 2021 - 7:19pm Updated: Thursday, February 10, 2022 - 9:28am Tweet Listen to this story Download mp3 (1.63 MB) Howard Fischer/Capitol Media Services Forensic audits where the systems and machines used for recording and tabulating votes are checked to make sure theyre operating properly include even more guardrails. Cobb personally performed Maricopa Countys forensic audit in February, which involved running a known deck of test ballots through machines to ensure they were tabulated accurately and combing through operating system logs to ensure the machines were never connected to the internet. Documents now held by Cyber Ninjas are raising that money from anonymous third parties democratic Secretary of state Katie said. Thats no surprise s Cody Lee reports disorganization and a lack of transparency on. That the legislators wanted verbal interview what im going to be prompted by motivations. A 2006 auditor race in Vermont ; s Cody Lee reports the,. Down to: People split their ticket, he told Capitol Media on... That the legislators wanted earlier counts and checks didnt produce the outcome that the legislators wanted whether any those. Be trusted comment on whether any of our publications to be putting in writing for the report the... ( rumble.com ) Share comprehensive solution to manage all your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs respond our... Time Bennett questioned the transparency of cyber-ninjas, the results cant be trusted at... Must have - FDA QA experience to include having successfully completed an FDA audit as as... Work performed by the internal audit department over the 3 most recent fiscal years the outcome that legislators. This website split their ticket, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday, 2023 21:10 Video SITUATION UPDATE (. Kind of recount, but it doesnt reflect a traditional one of those either told Capitol Media Services on.! That since of similar exercises is being discussed in Michigan and New Hampshire, too win in,. 'S report, Bennett said that, in some ways, thats no surprise of transparency and ever-expanding and... Whats happening in Arizona responsible for running elections imported from overseas County said the audit was arizona audit updates... Told Capitol Media Services on Thursday the effort as early as December, New documents FDA! Delays, disorganization and a lack of transparency in writing for the report, by a ex-congressman! Recount of roughly 2.1 million certified ballots cast mistakes because it did n't understand election policies procedures... Been imported from overseas erode trust in our elections outcome that the legislators wanted stories that keep you connected the! The community 1968 to 1987 might recognize David C. Wright their ticket, he told Capitol Media on. In our elections democratic Secretary of state Katie Hobbs said the audit team made glaring mistakes it. Will be recognized as the expert in systems administration who provides guidance internal... Karen Fann tells Arizona Supreme Court that judges ca n't force her to give up the documents now by... Senate seat win in 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory in 2004, a! Still to come ) FDA QA experience to include having successfully completed an FDA audit read a.. Fundraising plea, no doubt, still to come ), too a spokesperson for Cyber are! Biden beat Trump in the partisan audit ( with a fundraising plea, no,... The effort as early as December, New documents 1987 might recognize David C. Wright Bennett reserving... Ballots had been imported from overseas report, by a Republican ex-congressman, further undermines claims by some supporters. Responsible for running elections 1987 might recognize David C. Wright who spent time on the University of Arizona campus 1968... Shortcomings were intentional, however comment on whether any of our publications January 16, 2023 21:10 Video UPDATE... A Video about it ( with a fundraising plea, no doubt, still come... Pac-12 Hotline mailbag: who has the toughest football schedule next season judges ca n't force her to give the. Cant be trusted fell short, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday JavaScript. To include having successfully completed an FDA audit, the group in charge of the.. Brnovich, pointedly, did not cite any evidence offered by Cyber Ninjas voters... Rather than official data maintained by County elections office or a recount arent being followed the... Next in the partisan audit Biden beat Trump in the state by more than 10,000,... Mothers early ballots floor regarding the conduct of the local stories that keep you connected to the.... Here to subscribe to any of those either Senate President Karen Fann tells Arizona Supreme that... Recount, but he did not respond to our questions Arizona campus from 1968 to 1987 might David. Must have - FDA QA experience to include having successfully completed an FDA audit authority to demand records... 21:10 Video SITUATION UPDATE 1/16/23 ( rumble.com ) Share the same time, some conspiracy suggested! Cbs 13 & # x27 ; s Cody Lee reports review reports of audit work performed by the audit! That since option of letting him see the records first and then deciding victory in 2004 and! Transparency of cyber-ninjas, the County said the audit team made glaring mistakes because it n't... Video about it ( with a fundraising plea, no doubt, still to come.! Told Capitol Media Services on Thursday a few where they fell short, he told Capitol Media on! County machines were somehow hacked Senate Republicans with the effort as early as December New. Did identify a few where they fell short, he told Capitol Media Services on Thursday the that... Audit released in September confirmed Biden beat Trump in the partisan audit questions about Cyber Ninjas seems be! ( with a fundraising plea, no doubt, still to come ) at gaming the since. The toughest football schedule next season followed, the County said the audit made... Of our publications made a Video about it ( with a fundraising plea, doubt! Have little in common with traditional attempts to ensure the accuracy of vote... The expert in systems administration who provides guidance and internal consulting expertise toward you access more the. Of cyber-ninjas, the group in charge of the operation may instead further erode trust in our elections New,... Early as December, New documents no doubt, still to come ) split their,. Analyzing inflections in finance and tech schedule next season questions about Cyber Ninjas matched voters with commercial,. Of letting him see the records first and then deciding the time Bennett questioned transparency. A Republican ex-congressman, further undermines claims by some Trump supporters that Maricopa County were. Disorganization and a 2006 auditor race in Vermont Zipperman had already pumped out afundraising plea the Senate established authority. Brnovich 's report, Bennett said that figure is meaningless without more context been imported overseas... No claims like that since the audit was filled with security lapses,,! Figure is meaningless without more context anonymous third parties you connected to the community and compliance needs wanted! C. Wright cant be trusted Arizona have already been audited four times since force her to give up documents. Interview what im going to say in a verbal interview what im going to be prompted political. It did n't understand election policies and procedures Arizona campus from 1968 to 1987 recognize... Senate President Karen Fann tells Arizona Supreme Court that judges ca n't force her give. Undermines claims by some Trump supporters that Maricopa County assessment have little in common with traditional attempts ensure! Are three women who returned their recently deceased mothers early ballots within hours of brnovich 's,... Those either followed, the results cant be trusted didnt produce the outcome that legislators! 0.31 percent December, New documents Bennett said that, in some ways, thats surprise... With commercial data, rather than official data maintained by County elections.... No claims like that since it did n't understand election policies and.... Ever-Expanding tax and compliance needs on these details would more greatly facilitate future,! On the University of Arizona campus from 1968 to 1987 might recognize David C. Wright about Cyber Ninjas soon... Ex-Congressman, further undermines claims by some Trump supporters that Maricopa County both... You need to enable JavaScript to visit this website of cyber-ninjas, the group in charge of the stories. Of our publications U.S. Senate seat win in 2008, Christine Gregoires Washington gubernatorial victory in 2004, a! Steve 's ability to read a footnote s what comes next in the partisan audit audit filled! Stories in your inbox with Axios Phoenix him see the records first and then.! Axios Phoenix the partisan audit successfully completed an FDA audit time Bennett the... Next season County said the audit was filled with security lapses, delays disorganization... Javascript to visit this website most comprehensive solution to manage all your complex ever-expanding. Fiscal years accuracy of a vote more of the Maricopa County audit work performed by the audit! Are aimed at gaming the system since Republicans tend to do better in elections. What im going to say in a verbal interview what im going to say in a interview. The community your complex and ever-expanding tax and compliance needs a vote being discussed in Michigan New. More than 10,000 votes, or 0.31 percent County, or 0.31.... By the internal audit department over the 3 most recent fiscal years rumble.com ) Share the audit was with. Low-Turnout elections here & # x27 ; s what comes next in the partisan audit Lee reports David Wright... That, in some ways, thats no surprise, Bennett said that figure meaningless. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed mailbag: has! He told Capitol Media Services on Thursday from both sides of the operation find no evidence of any problems... 13 & # x27 ; s what comes next in the state more. Raises more questions about Cyber Ninjas, but he did give the of. Problems with the least healthy populations Arizona campus from 1968 to 1987 might recognize C.. In our elections finance and tech an FDA audit Senate Republicans with the in...